Best Pool Cleaner in 2024: Reviews and Comparisons

    Having a great pool cleaner is an easy and convenient way to keep your pool clean all summer. But with that said, there are a lot of different pool cleaners on the market, and depending on what kind of pool you own and your particular situation will depend on which one is right for you.

    Our Top Picks

    After researching dozens of pool cleaners and testing several hands-on, here are our top picks for best robotic, suction-side, and self-propelled pool cleaners:

    Pool Cleaner Review: Best Option for Your Pool's Needs

    Keeping your pool clean is essential for safe and enjoyable swimming. Manual cleaning can be time-consuming and tedious. A good pool cleaner can save you effort while maintaining water clarity and hygiene.

    1. Dolphin Nautilus CC Plus

    So first up, we have the best overall pool vacuum and that's going to be the Dolphin Nautilus CC Plus. Now this is the best robotic pool cleaner for any kind of pool. It works for inground pools, including vinyl, tile, and cement. It has a tangle-free cable and it also has superior filtering abilities.

    Type: Robotic Pool Cleaner

    Pool Type: In-Ground

    Cleaning Method: Scrub and vacuum the dirt


    ✔️  Strong suction power up to 4500 GPH for thorough cleaning 

    ✔️  Its sophisticated multi-stage filtration traps even the tiniest particles

    ✔️  Intelligent navigation covers the entire pool

    ✔️  Simple setup and easy to use


    ❌  Can't connect to your smartphone for control

    Dolphin Nautilus CC Plus can tackle even the toughest debris. It also features incredibly powerful scrubbing brushes and it's very energy efficient so it's not going to eat up your power bill. Also, in terms of ease of use, this is a very user-friendly option. It has great, easy-to-remove cartridges to make sure that swapping them out is a breeze. Also, one great thing about this one is it will actually clean the base walls and stairs of your pool with wall-climbing capabilities.


    Just connect the power cord, drop the robot into your pool, and turn it on. Then sit back, relax, and let the Dolphin get to work sanitizing your entire pool. The Dolphin's intelligent navigation system methodically cleans every inch of your pool's floor, walls, and waterline. Its powerful suction lifts away the debris as small as 5 microns, capturing even the finest dust particles that cloud your pool water.

    Our Experience: This is ideal for larger pool sizes of up to 50 feet and the standard cleaning time is about two hours.

    In just 2 hours, you'll have a spotless pool without heavy lifting or dragging hoses. The Dolphin does the dirty work so you don't have to, returning your pool to a pristine state so you can enjoy it all summer long.


    2. Hayward W3PVS40JST

    Now the Hayward W3PVS40JST pool cleaner is a great option for average-size pools and it actually does come with a 4-wheel drive. That means that if there are any obstacles encountered in your pool, it can get up and over them and clean them with ease.


    Type: Pressure-Side Pool Cleaners

    Pool Type: In-Ground

    Cleaning Method: Vacuum the dirt and trash



    ✔️  Adjustable speed according to the pool's needs, which can save energy

    ✔️  Quiet operation without being disturbed by the noise of the pump

    ✔️  Made of high-quality materials and is designed to last for a long time


    ❌  More expensive than traditional single-speed pumps

    ❌  The pump requires professional installation


    It also does have a tool wheel drive option for those on a tighter budget. To let it work you must have a pump and need at least a 1/2 horsepower pump to make it work. It actually features turbine vanes that are self-adjusting, which means that it has maximum power at any pressure, which is a really great feature. It also has the ability to climb walls and overcome any obstacle that you throw at it, thus maximizing the pool coverage.

    Our Experience: It's a great option for pool sizes up to 20 ft and 40 ft depending on the model that you choose, and it can clean deep ends as well.

    Also with this one, it does come with variable size throats, which means it can clean different types of debris. So if you're looking for the best automatic pool vacuum, definitely check out the pool cleaner. 


    3. Zodiac G3 Automatic Suction-Side

    Zodiac Barracuda G3 pool cleaner is both silent and powerful. It gives you maximum efficiency even with a low-pressure pump. This is suitable for cleaning floors, walls, and even the steps of your swimming pool. It does feature a flow keeper valve that will maintain a regular water flow so the pool can be cleaned thoroughly.


    Type: Suction-Side Pool Cleaners
    Pool Type: In-Ground
    Cleaning Method: Vacuum all sides of the pool


    ✔️  Affordable compared to other pool cleaners on the market

    ✔️  Easy to install without the need for professional help

    ✔️  Designed to clean both the walls and floors of your pool

    ✔️  G3 doesn't require electricity to operate, relying instead on the suction from your pool's pump,


    ❌  Some users report that the Zodiac G3 can get stuck on steps or corners

    This one is also incredibly durable and it will last longer than other cleaners. It does only have one moving part, which means that it will stick around for a long time. 1 great thing here is it's great for all types of pool surfaces, including tile, vinyl, and concrete. It also has a wheel deflector that helps it move around difficult or tight corners. It does come with a scuff-resistant hose and it's definitely built to last. 

    Our Experience: Because of comes with a 36-foot hose, if your pool is larger than 36 feet in length, you may need to purchase additional hose sections to ensure that the G3 can effectively clean your pool.


    4. AIPER Seagull Pro

    We were very impressed and excited to get AIPER Seagull Pro tested out on my pool. The Seagull Pro lasts up to 180 minutes of work time with a quad motor system, and smart navigation and is ideal for in-ground pools up to 3200 square feet. It also comes with this retrieval so that you can go ahead and hook it once the Seagull Pro has completed its cleaning. You'll utilize this in order to retrieve it out of your pool and there is also the power supply and charger and very easily you'll just take the cable. 


    Type: Robotic Pool Cleaner

    Pool Type: Above/In-Ground Pools

    Cleaning Method: Scrub and vacuum the dirt



    ✔️  Strong suction power up to 4500 GPH for thorough cleaning 

    ✔️  Its sophisticated multi-stage filtration traps even the tiniest particles

    ✔️  Intelligent navigation covers the entire pool

    ✔️  Simple setup and easy to use


    ❌  Can't connect to your smartphone for control

    The robotic pool cleaner can climb your pool wall easily and scrub the water line effectively. As such, not only the pool floor is cleaned, but also the walls and even the water surface.

    WavePath navigation allows pool vacuums to work on a specific and fixed route, they move in rows ( row-by-row) to clean which results in higher cleaning performance instead of like traditional models that move randomly.


    Once it is fully charged, which takes about 90 minutes, you'll want to remove the charger. Be sure to place that cover right back in there and you'll be good to go. There are three main operating modes that are controlled by a power switch on the pool cleaner body.

    Our Experience: It's worth noting that the Seagull Pro is a relatively heavy pool cleaner, weighing around 25 pounds. This may make it difficult to lift and move around, especially for older or less physically capable pool owners. 

    On the back here of the seagull pro there is a hatch so you would just lift that little door up and you can reach the waste basket. So all the dust and trash that the robot cleans will get trapped in here, making it nice and easy to just take it out for cleaning and store it for the next cleaning. Seagull Pro's certainly not a cheap build, it is built to last.


    5. Pentair GW9500

    Pentair GW9500 Kreepy Krauly doesn't just suck, it will actually scrub the floor of your pool, loosening up that tight grit. This is a great option for different types of pools, including incline dishes and hopper bottoms. Pentair GW9500 also has the ability to work on a number of different pool surfaces, including vinyl, fiberglass, and gunite.


    Type: Suction-Side Pool Cleaners
    Pool Type: In-Ground Pool
    Cleaning Method: Scrub and vacuum the dirt


    ✔️  Comes with a programmable timer that allows you to set cleaning cycles for your pool

    ✔️  Easy to install and operate, with a simple design

    ✔️  Effectively clean the floors, walls, and waterline


    ❌  May not work well with low-speed pumps

    Again, this is a great option to reach all of those difficult-to-reach spots, and it's super easy to use. All you have to do is attach the hose and place it in the water and it will do all the cleaning on its own. Just note that this one can't climb stairs.

    Our Experience: It's a good option for pool owners who want a low-maintenance pool cleaning solution that is an affordable option.

    However, it does let you adjust the device to get effective cleaning. So if you do have an in-ground pool and you're looking for the best option, definitely check out the Pentair Kreepy Krauly. 


    6.  POOLWHALE Skimmer Net

    The POOLWHALE Skimmer Net is an effective tool for removing debris and particles from the surface of swimming pools. Its wide 14-inch pickup area allows it to cover a large surface area of the pool in one pass, efficiently collecting dirt, leaves, and other debris floating on the water. 


    Type: Accessory 

    Pool Type: Above/In-Ground Pool

    Cleaning Method: Skimming



    ✔️  An affordable option for pool owners who want a basic cleaning tool 

    ✔️  Compatible with most telescopic poles for attaching to existing pool cleaning equipment.


    ❌  Can only be used to remove leaves and debris from the surface

    The soft, fine mesh nylon netting is gentle on hands and won't damage pool surfaces while the ergonomic foam handle provides a comfortable grip even when wet, making it easier to use for longer periods.


    The pole and net frame are constructed from durable, rust-resistant galvanized steel built to last for years of use. Additionally, the net's floating design makes it simple to position and maneuver around the pool. When finished, the net conveniently folds up and can be stored on its wall mount bracket, keeping it neat and organized.

    Our Experience: Easy to handle and lightweight, making it simple to use for basic pool cleaning tasks

    Buying Guide

    Pool cleaners are devices designed to remove dirt, debris, and other contaminants from your pool, keeping it clean and healthy for swimming. With so many different types and models of pool cleaners available, choosing the best one for your needs can be overwhelming.

    Type of pool cleaner: There are three main types of pool cleaners – suction-side, pressure-side, and robotic. Each type has its own advantages and disadvantages, so it's important to choose the type that best suits your needs. Suction-side cleaners are affordable and easy to use, pressure-side cleaners are powerful and efficient, and robotic cleaners are convenient and effective.

    The most popular type of swimming pool that appears in most American homes today is the in-ground pool. For this type of swimming pool, all pool cleaners can work. You can see Hayward W3PVS40JST and Pentair GW9500 are suction side types that work very well on this model.

    Size of your pool: The size of your pool will determine the size of the pool cleaner you need. Be sure to measure your pool and consult the manufacturer's specifications before purchasing a pool cleaner to ensure that it's the right size for your pool.

    Usually, the most important thing you need to pay attention to is the length of the water hose when connecting to the pump. It will limit the cleaning range of the pool cleaner. However, you can absolutely buy and use extra hoses to increase the length of the water hose.

    Type of pool surface: Different pool cleaners are designed for use on different types of pool surfaces, such as concrete, vinyl, or fiberglass. Be sure to choose a pool cleaner that is compatible with your pool's surface to avoid damage.

    Amount of debris: If your pool is prone to accumulating a lot of debris, such as leaves or twigs, you may need a more powerful pool cleaner to effectively remove the debris.

    Dirt and litter can come from the areas around the pool, especially in dense gardens where you can't stop the leaves from falling. Then not only the pool floor need to be cleaned but even the water surface will be covered with leaves and trash if not cleaned regularly. You can use high-end AIPER Seagull Pro products that can suck up all the trash in the pool or you can combine the use of racket accessories for regular cleaning.

    Filtration system: The effectiveness of your pool cleaner may be affected by the condition of your pool's filtration system. Be sure to clean or replace your pool's filter regularly to ensure that your pool cleaner can operate at maximum efficiency.

    Budget: Pool cleaners can range in price from a few hundred to a few thousand dollars, so it's important to consider your budget when choosing a pool cleaner. While more expensive pool cleaners may offer additional features or better performance, there are still many affordable options available that can effectively clean your pool.

    Brand reputation: Look for pool cleaners from reputable brands with good customer reviews and warranties. This can help ensure that you're investing in a high-quality product that will last for many years.

    Editor’s Verdict

    If you need a robotic pool cleaner that can tackle extra-large pools efficiently, I'd highly recommend the Dolphin Nautilus CC Plus. This handy little robot does a great job navigating your pool on its own. It uses intelligent sensors to detect and avoid obstacles as it makes its way through the water, ensuring it covers every nook and cranny. I like that Dolphin backs this product with a solid 5-year warranty. It shows they stand behind quality and performance.

    Customers say the Nautilus excels at maneuvering pools of various shapes and sizes while still providing powerful suction and cleaning action. So if you've got a huge pool that needs a robotic cleaner it can handle, this is a great option.

    Or if you're looking for an automatic pool cleaner that's effective yet affordable, the Hayward W3PVS40JST fits the bill. This basic cleaner uses a simple, no-frills design that has a proven track record of thoroughly cleaning most average-sized residential pools. While it lacks fancy features, what it provides is a reliable performance at an entry-level price.

    Being a well-established name in pool equipment, you can feel confident Hayward will stand behind its product. Customers say this cleaner does an awesome job keeping pools clean with minimal hassle.


    1. How often should I run my pool cleaner? 

    It depends on the type and pool size. As a guideline, run robotic cleaners once per day for 4-6 hours, suction/pressure cleaners 3-4 times per week for 3-4 hours, and manual cleaners after each use or at least once a week. Run them more often during peak swimming seasons.

    2. What is the best way to maintain my pool cleaner? 

    Clean filters at least monthly or as needed, inspect hoses and connections yearly for damage and tighten loose parts, replace worn parts like brushes annually, add bleach monthly to the compartment to prevent bacteria buildup and rinse debris traps after each use. For winter storage, fully charge batteries, raise cleaners off the floor, and store them indoors in a cool, dry place. With proper routine maintenance, your pool cleaner will perform well for many years.

    3. What are the most common pool cleaner issues? 

    The most common issues are clogs, debris collection problems, leaks, and mechanical or electrical failure. To avoid these, clean filters regularly, check hoses and straps regularly for damage, empty debris collection bins as needed, store cleaners properly over winter, only use cleaners in compatible pools, and follow the manufacturer's maintenance schedule.


    Choosing the best pool cleaner for your needs can seem overwhelming due to the many options, features, and considerations. By considering key factors like type, size, features, durability, price, and reviews – and choosing a pool cleaner that is tailored to your unique pool and lifestyle – you'll end up with the best option for keeping your pool clean and hassle-free for the long run.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *